Practical Dictionary Attack On IPsec IKE

We found out that in contrast to public knowledge, the Pre-Shared Key (PSK) authentication method in main mode of IKEv1 is susceptible to offline dictionary attacks. This requires only a single active Man-in-the-Middle attack. Thus, if low entropy passwords are used as PSKs, this can easily be broken.

This week at the USENIX Security conference, Dennis Felsch will present our research paper on IPsec attacksThe Dangers of Key Reuse: Practical Attacks on IPsec IKE. [alternative link to the paper]

In his blog post, Dennis showed how to attack the public key encryption based authentication methods of IKEv1 (PKE & RPKE) and how to use this attack against IKEv2 signature based authentication method. In this blog post, I will focus on another interesting finding regarding IKEv1 and the Pre-Shared Key authentication.

IPsec and Internet Key Exchange (IKE)

IPsec enables cryptographic protection of IP packets. It is commonly used to build VPNs (Virtual Private Networks). For key establishment, the IKE protocol is used. IKE exists in two versions, each with different modes, different phases, several authentication methods, and configuration options. Therefore, IKE is one of the most complex cryptographic protocols in use.

In version 1 of IKE (IKEv1), four authentication methods are available for Phase 1, in which initial authenticated keying material is established: Two public key encryption based methods, one signature based method, and a PSK (Pre-Shared Key) based method.

The relationship between IKEv1 Phase 1, Phase 2, and IPsec ESP. Multiple simultaneous Phase 2 connections can be established from a single Phase 1 connection. Grey parts are encrypted, either with IKE derived keys (light grey) or with IPsec keys (dark grey). The numbers at the curly brackets denote the number of messages to be exchanged in the protocol.

Pre-Shared Key authentication

As shown above, Pre-Shared Key authentication is one of three authentication methods in IKEv1. The authentication is based on the knowledge of a shared secret string. In reality, this is probably some sort of password.

The IKEv1 handshake for PSK authentication looks like the following (simplified version):


In the first two messages, the session identifier (inside HDR) and the cryptographic algorithms (proposals) are selected by initiator and responder. 

In messages 3 and 4, they exchange ephemeral Diffie-Hellman shares and nonces. After that, they compute a key k by using their shared secret (PSK) in a PRF function (e.g. HMAC-SHA1) and the previously exchanged nonces. This key is used to derive additional keys (ka, kd, ke). The key kd is used to compute MACI over the session identifier and the shared diffie-hellman secret gxy. Finally, the key ke is used to encrypt IDI (e.g. IPv4 address of the peer) and MACI

Weaknesses of PSK authentication

It is well known that the aggressive mode of authentication in combination with PSK is insecure and vulnerable against off-line dictionary attacks, by simply eavesedropping the packets. For example, in strongSwan it is necessary to set the following configuration flag in order to use it:
charon.i_dont_care_about_security_and_use_aggressive_mode_psk=yes

For the main mode, we found a similar attack when doing some minor additional work. For that, the attacker needs to waits until a peer A (initiator) tries to connect to another peer B (responder). Then, the attacker acts as a man-in-the middle and behaves like the peer B would, but does not forward the packets to B.

From the picture above it should be clear that an attacker who acts as B can compute (gxy) and receives the necessary public values session ID, nI, nR. However, the attacker does not know the PSK. In order to mount a dictionary attack against this value, he uses the nonces, and computes a candidate for for every entry in the dictionary. It is necessary to make a key derivation for every k with the values of the session identifiers and shared Diffie-Hellmann secret the possible keys ka, kd and ke. Then, the attacker uses ke in order to decrypt the encrypted part of message 5. Due to IDI often being an IP address plus some additional data of the initiator, the attacker can easily determine if the correct PSK has been found.

Who is affected?

This weakness exists in the IKEv1 standard (RFC 2409). Every software or hardware that is compliant to this standard is affected. Therefore, we encourage all vendors, companies, and developers to at least ensure that high-entropy Pre-Shared Keys are used in IKEv1 configurations.

In order to verify the attack, we tested the attack against strongSWAN 5.5.1.

Proof-of-Concept

We have implemented a PoC that runs a dictionary attack against a network capture (pcapng) of a IKEv1 main mode session. As input, it also requires the Diffie-Hellmann secret as described above. You can find the source code at github. We only tested the attack against strongSWAN 5.5.1. If you want to use the PoC against another implementation or session, you have to adjust the idHex value in main.py.

Responsible Disclosure

We reported our findings to the international CERT at July 6th, 2018. We were informed that they contacted over 250 parties about the weakness. The CVE ID for it is CVE-2018-5389 [cert entry].

Credits

On August 10th, 2018, we learned that this attack against IKEv1 main mode with PSKs was previously described by David McGrew in his blog post Great Cipher, But Where Did You Get That Key?. We would like to point out that neither we nor the USENIX reviewers nor the CERT were obviously aware of this.
On August 14th 2018, Graham Bartlett (Cisco) email us that he presented the weakness of PSK in IKEv2 in several public presentations and in his book.
On August 15th 2018, we were informed by Tamir Zegman that John Pliam described the attack on his web page in 1999.

FAQs

  • Do you have a name, logo, any merchandising for the attack?
    No.
  • Have I been attacked?
    We mentioned above that such an attack would require an active man-in-the-middle attack. In the logs this could look like a failed connection attempt or a session timed out. But this is a rather weak indication and no evidence for an attack. 
  • What should I do?
    If you do not have the option to switch to authentication with digital signatures, choose a Pre-Shared Key that resists dictionary attacks. If you want to achieve e.g. 128 bits of security, configure a PSK with at least 19 random ASCII characters. And do not use something that can be found in public databases.
  • Am I safe if I use PSKs with IKEv2?
    No, interestingly the standard also mentions that IKEv2 does not prevent against off-line dictionary attacks.
  • Where can I learn more?
    You can read the paper[alternative link to the paper]
  • What else does the paper contain?
    The paper contains a lot more details than this blogpost. It explains all authentication methods of IKEv1 and it gives message flow diagrams of the protocol. There, we describe a variant of the attack that uses the Bleichenbacher oracles to forge signatures to target IKEv2. 

More articles


  1. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
  2. Hack Tools For Pc
  3. New Hacker Tools
  4. Hacker
  5. Hacking Tools Software
  6. Tools Used For Hacking
  7. Hacker Tools Free Download
  8. Pentest Tools Download
  9. Nsa Hack Tools Download
  10. Pentest Tools Website
  11. Wifi Hacker Tools For Windows
  12. Underground Hacker Sites
  13. Pentest Tools Online
  14. Best Hacking Tools 2019
  15. Pentest Tools Download
  16. Hacking Tools For Games
  17. Computer Hacker
  18. Hacking Tools For Pc
  19. Hacking Tools Usb
  20. Hacking Apps
  21. Hack Tool Apk
  22. Hack Tools Mac
  23. Pentest Tools Windows
  24. Pentest Tools Framework
  25. Hacking Tools For Windows
  26. Hacker Tools Software
  27. Best Hacking Tools 2019
  28. Pentest Tools Linux
  29. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
  30. Hack App
  31. Hack Tools 2019
  32. Hack App
  33. Beginner Hacker Tools
  34. Hacking Tools Windows
  35. Pentest Box Tools Download
  36. Pentest Tools
  37. Free Pentest Tools For Windows
  38. Hack Tool Apk No Root
  39. Hack App
  40. Hacker Tools Windows
  41. Pentest Recon Tools
  42. Best Hacking Tools 2020
  43. Pentest Tools For Windows
  44. Top Pentest Tools
  45. Pentest Tools Framework
  46. Pentest Tools Framework
  47. Hacking Tools For Windows
  48. Tools 4 Hack
  49. Hacking Tools Pc
  50. Hack Tools For Mac
  51. Hacker Hardware Tools
  52. Hacker Tools Mac
  53. Pentest Tools Website Vulnerability
  54. Hacker Tools Hardware
  55. Tools 4 Hack
  56. Pentest Tools Url Fuzzer
  57. Hacker Tools Apk Download
  58. What Is Hacking Tools
  59. Pentest Tools Subdomain
  60. Wifi Hacker Tools For Windows
  61. Pentest Tools Port Scanner
  62. Hacking Tools 2019
  63. Hacker Tools Apk
  64. Hacking Tools And Software
  65. Hacking Tools Pc
  66. Hack Tools For Mac
  67. Nsa Hack Tools
  68. Hack Tools For Mac
  69. Hacking App
  70. Pentest Tools For Mac
  71. Hacking Tools Windows
  72. Hacking Tools And Software
  73. Usb Pentest Tools
  74. Hacker Tools Windows
  75. Pentest Tools Windows
  76. How To Install Pentest Tools In Ubuntu
  77. Pentest Tools List
  78. Hackrf Tools
  79. Hacking Tools Software
  80. Tools Used For Hacking
  81. Pentest Tools Website
  82. Blackhat Hacker Tools
  83. Bluetooth Hacking Tools Kali
  84. Hacks And Tools
  85. Pentest Tools Website Vulnerability
  86. Pentest Tools For Ubuntu
  87. Pentest Reporting Tools
  88. Hack Tools Pc
  89. Pentest Tools Free
  90. What Is Hacking Tools
  91. Hacking Tools 2019
  92. Hacking Apps
  93. Hack Tools Mac
  94. Hack Tools Mac
  95. Hack Tools For Pc
  96. Pentest Tools Free
  97. Hacking Tools Online
  98. Hacker Tools Free Download
  99. Pentest Tools Bluekeep
  100. Beginner Hacker Tools
  101. Hacker Tools 2019
  102. Nsa Hack Tools Download
  103. Hacker Tool Kit
  104. Black Hat Hacker Tools
  105. Pentest Tools Windows
  106. Hacking Tools Github
  107. Hack Tools Mac
  108. Hacks And Tools
  109. Hacker Tools For Ios
  110. Hacking Tools Mac
  111. Wifi Hacker Tools For Windows
  112. Hacker Tools Mac
  113. Pentest Tools Tcp Port Scanner
  114. Hacking Tools For Games
  115. Hacker Tools For Windows
  116. Growth Hacker Tools
  117. Pentest Tools For Mac
  118. How To Install Pentest Tools In Ubuntu
  119. Hacker Tools For Mac
  120. Hack Website Online Tool
  121. Wifi Hacker Tools For Windows
  122. Computer Hacker
  123. Tools For Hacker
  124. Hacks And Tools
  125. Hack Tools For Pc

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Remember...

If you want more information on any of these news updates, do feel free to call the office at any time! 02890673379
or email office@summermadness.co.uk
....or check out the rest of the SM website